article-writing
Structure and style guidance for law review articles
When & Why to Use This Skill
This Claude skill provides comprehensive structure and style guidance for law review articles, helping legal scholars and students organize complex research into professional academic formats. It offers detailed frameworks for doctrinal, empirical, and interdisciplinary scholarship, ensuring adherence to standard legal writing conventions, IRAC paragraph structures, and publication-ready length calibrations.
Use Cases
- Developing a professional outline for legal academic papers, ensuring all critical components like the thesis statement, contribution claim, and roadmap are properly placed.
- Refining the writing style of legal drafts by applying specific rules such as active voice, elimination of nominalizations, and removal of 'throat-clearing' introductory phrases.
- Calibrating article length and footnote density to meet the specific requirements of different publication types, from student notes to major academic pieces.
- Conducting a final quality check on legal manuscripts using a comprehensive checklist to verify argumentative rigor, smooth transitions, and citation support.
| name | Article Writing |
|---|---|
| description | Structure and style guidance for law review articles |
| version | 1.0.0 |
Law Review Article Writing Skill
Domain: Legal academic article structure and style Version: 1.0.0 Last Updated: 2025-12-15
Overview
This skill provides guidance for structuring and writing law review articles, including traditional doctrinal pieces, empirical studies, and interdisciplinary scholarship.
Standard Article Structure
I. Introduction (5-10% of article)
Purpose: Hook the reader, state the thesis, roadmap the article.
Elements:
- Opening hook - Compelling case, statistic, or puzzle
- Problem statement - What issue does this article address?
- Thesis statement - What does this article argue?
- Contribution claim - Why does this matter? What's new?
- Roadmap - Brief preview of article structure
Example opening patterns:
- Case study opening: "In Smith v. Jones, the court faced..."
- Puzzle opening: "Legal scholars have long assumed X, but..."
- Stakes opening: "Every year, thousands of defendants..."
- Counter-intuitive opening: "Conventional wisdom holds that..."
II. Background/Context (15-20%)
Purpose: Give readers necessary context without rehashing basics.
Elements:
- Legal doctrine overview (only what's needed)
- Historical development (if relevant)
- Current state of scholarship
- Gap identification (what's missing?)
Calibration: Assume reader is smart lawyer unfamiliar with this specific area.
III. Core Argument (40-50%)
Purpose: Develop and support the thesis.
Structure options:
Linear argument:
A. First supporting claim
1. Evidence/authority
2. Analysis
B. Second supporting claim
1. Evidence/authority
2. Analysis
C. Third supporting claim
...
Problem-solution:
A. Problem detailed
B. Existing solutions critiqued
C. Proposed solution
D. Solution defended
Case study driven:
A. Case 1 analysis
B. Case 2 analysis
C. Pattern identification
D. Theoretical implications
IV. Counterarguments (10-15%)
Purpose: Acknowledge and respond to objections.
Best practices:
- State opposing view fairly and strongly
- Distinguish weak vs. strong objections
- Provide substantive responses
- Concede points where appropriate
V. Implications/Applications (10-15%)
Purpose: Show what follows from your argument.
Elements:
- Doctrinal implications
- Policy recommendations
- Future research directions
- Limitations acknowledgment
VI. Conclusion (5%)
Purpose: Synthesize and close.
Elements:
- Restate thesis (fresh language)
- Summarize key contributions
- End with broader significance or call to action
Writing Style Guidelines
Voice and Tone
- Authoritative but not arrogant - State claims confidently, acknowledge limitations
- Precise - Legal writing demands exactness
- Accessible - Avoid unnecessary jargon
- Engaging - Vary sentence structure, use active voice
Common Style Rules
Prefer active voice
- Weak: "The statute was interpreted by the court..."
- Strong: "The court interpreted the statute..."
Avoid nominalizations
- Weak: "The implementation of the policy..."
- Strong: "Implementing the policy..."
Be specific
- Weak: "Courts have generally held..."
- Strong: "The Second Circuit has consistently held..."
Use strong verbs
- Weak: "The defendant made an argument that..."
- Strong: "The defendant argued that..."
Eliminate throat-clearing
- Cut: "It is important to note that..."
- Cut: "It should be emphasized that..."
- Cut: "It goes without saying that..."
Paragraph Structure
IRAC for analytical paragraphs:
- Issue - What question does this paragraph address?
- Rule - What legal principle applies?
- Analysis - How does the rule apply to facts?
- Conclusion - What follows?
Topic sentences:
- Every paragraph needs a clear topic sentence
- Topic sentence should advance the argument
- Reader should understand paragraph's point from first sentence
Transition Strategies
Between sections:
- End section with forward reference
- Begin section with backward reference
- Use explicit transition sentences
Between paragraphs:
- Logical connectors (however, moreover, therefore)
- Reference to previous paragraph's conclusion
- Parallel structure
Footnote Density
Academic standard: Approximately 1 footnote per 2-3 sentences of text.
When to footnote:
- Direct quotations (always)
- Specific claims of fact
- Legal rules and holdings
- Others' arguments you're engaging
- Supporting examples
When NOT to footnote:
- Your own original analysis
- General knowledge
- Logical deductions from cited premises
Length Calibration
| Article Type | Word Count | Footnotes |
|---|---|---|
| Student Note | 15,000-25,000 | 150-300 |
| Standard Article | 20,000-35,000 | 200-400 |
| Major Piece | 30,000-50,000 | 300-500 |
| Essay/Commentary | 5,000-10,000 | 50-100 |
Available Workflows
workflows/structure-argument.md- Develop article outlineworkflows/integrate-sources.md- Weave sources into argumentworkflows/peer-review-prep.md- Prepare for submission
Quality Checklist
Before completion, verify:
- Thesis clearly stated in introduction
- Each section advances the central argument
- Counterarguments addressed fairly
- Citations support claims made
- Transitions smooth between sections
- Conclusion synthesizes without mere repetition
- No unsupported assertions
- Voice consistent throughout
Legal scholarship persuades through rigorous argument and careful evidence.