The Ethics Review skill provides a comprehensive framework for conducting ethical impact assessments and stakeholder analysis for AI and technology projects. It helps organizations implement responsible innovation by identifying potential harms, ensuring algorithmic fairness, and establishing clear accountability through structured templates and ethical checklists. This tool is essential for teams looking to build trust and ensure their technology aligns with global ethical standards and safety guardrails.
Use Cases
Conducting a formal Ethical Impact Assessment (EIA) to identify and mitigate risks before launching new AI features or technology systems.
Performing deep stakeholder analysis to evaluate how technology affects direct users, indirect parties, and vulnerable populations.
Using the AI Ethics Checklist to audit models for bias, transparency, explainability, and human-in-the-loop control mechanisms.
Establishing an Ethics Review Board (ERB) structure with defined decision-making frameworks and review thresholds for high-risk applications.
Integrating 'Ethics-by-Design' into the software development lifecycle (SDLC) to ensure responsible innovation from ideation to deployment.
name
ethics-review
description
AI and technology ethics review including ethical impact assessment, stakeholder analysis, and responsible innovation frameworks
allowed-tools
Read, Glob, Grep, Write, Edit, Task
Ethics Review
Comprehensive guidance for ethical assessment of technology systems, AI applications, and responsible innovation.
When to Use This Skill
Conducting ethical impact assessments for new projects
Evaluating AI systems for ethical risks
Establishing ethics review boards and processes
Developing ethical guidelines for technology teams
Assessing stakeholder impacts and potential harms
Core Ethical Principles
Foundation Principles
Principle
Description
Application
Beneficence
Do good, maximize benefits
Design for positive outcomes
Non-maleficence
Do no harm, minimize risks
Identify and mitigate harms
Autonomy
Respect individual choice
Informed consent, opt-out
Justice
Fair distribution of benefits/burdens
Equitable access, no discrimination
Transparency
Open about how systems work
Explainable AI, clear documentation
Accountability
Clear responsibility
Ownership, audit trails
Privacy
Protect personal information
Data minimization, consent
Technology-Specific Principles
AI/ML Systems:
├── Fairness - Equitable treatment across groups
├── Explainability - Understandable decisions
├── Reliability - Consistent, predictable behavior
├── Safety - Prevent harm, fail safely
├── Privacy - Protect personal data
├── Security - Resist adversarial attacks
├── Inclusiveness - Accessible to all users
└── Human Control - Meaningful human oversight
# Ethical Impact Assessment
## 1. System Description
### Purpose
[What is the system designed to do?]
### Capabilities
[What can the system do? What decisions does it make or influence?]
### Context
[Where and how will the system be used?]
### Data
[What data does the system use? How is it collected?]
---
## 2. Stakeholder Analysis
### Direct Stakeholders
| Stakeholder | Relationship | Interests | Power | Concerns |
|-------------|--------------|-----------|-------|----------|
| [Group] | [Relationship] | [Interests] | [H/M/L] | [Concerns] |
### Indirect Stakeholders
| Stakeholder | How Affected | Interests | Concerns |
|-------------|--------------|-----------|----------|
| [Group] | [Impact] | [Interests] | [Concerns] |
### Vulnerable Groups
| Group | Vulnerability | Special Considerations |
|-------|---------------|----------------------|
| [Group] | [Why vulnerable] | [Protections needed] |
---
## 3. Impact Assessment
### Benefits
| Benefit | Beneficiary | Magnitude | Likelihood |
|---------|-------------|-----------|------------|
| [Benefit] | [Who] | [H/M/L] | [H/M/L] |
### Potential Harms
| Harm | Affected Group | Severity | Likelihood | Reversible? |
|------|----------------|----------|------------|-------------|
| [Harm] | [Who] | [H/M/L] | [H/M/L] | [Y/N] |
### Unintended Consequences
| Consequence | Description | Risk Level |
|-------------|-------------|------------|
| [Consequence] | [Details] | [H/M/L] |
---
## 4. Ethical Analysis
### Principle Evaluation
| Principle | Supports | Tensions | Score (1-5) |
|-----------|----------|----------|-------------|
| Beneficence | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
| Non-maleficence | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
| Autonomy | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
| Justice | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
| Transparency | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
| Accountability | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
| Privacy | [How] | [Conflicts] | [Score] |
### Ethical Dilemmas
| Dilemma | Trade-off | Proposed Resolution |
|---------|-----------|---------------------|
| [Dilemma] | [Trade-off] | [Resolution] |
---
## 5. Mitigation Plan
### Technical Mitigations
| Risk | Mitigation | Owner | Status |
|------|------------|-------|--------|
| [Risk] | [Control] | [Who] | [Status] |
### Procedural Mitigations
| Risk | Mitigation | Owner | Status |
|------|------------|-------|--------|
| [Risk] | [Process] | [Who] | [Status] |
### Monitoring Plan
| Metric | Threshold | Frequency | Response |
|--------|-----------|-----------|----------|
| [Metric] | [Limit] | [How often] | [Action] |
---
## 6. Decision
### Recommendation
[ ] Approve - Proceed with current design
[ ] Approve with conditions - Proceed after mitigations
[ ] Defer - Requires further analysis
[ ] Reject - Unacceptable ethical risks
### Conditions (if applicable)
1. [Condition]
2. [Condition]
### Review Schedule
- Initial review: [Date]
- Ongoing review: [Frequency]
### Approvals
| Role | Name | Decision | Date |
|------|------|----------|------|
| Ethics Board | | [ ] | |
| Technical Lead | | [ ] | |
| Business Owner | | [ ] | |
| Legal | | [ ] | |
Harm Assessment Framework
Categories of Harm
Direct Harms:
├── Physical harm to individuals
├── Psychological harm (stress, manipulation)
├── Financial harm (fraud, loss)
├── Privacy harm (exposure, surveillance)
├── Discrimination harm (unfair treatment)
└── Autonomy harm (manipulation, coercion)
Indirect/Systemic Harms:
├── Environmental harm
├── Democratic harm (manipulation, division)
├── Economic harm (displacement, inequality)
├── Social harm (erosion of trust, relationships)
└── Cultural harm (homogenization, loss)
Group-Specific Harms:
├── Harm to marginalized groups
├── Harm to vulnerable populations
├── Harm to future generations
└── Harm to non-users
Harm Severity Matrix
REVERSIBILITY
Easy Difficult Permanent
S Low 1 2 3
E Medium 2 4 6
V High 3 6 9
E Extreme 4 8 12
R
I
T
Y
Score:
1-2: Acceptable with monitoring
3-4: Requires mitigation
6-8: Significant controls required
9-12: May be unacceptable
AI Ethics Specifics
AI Ethics Checklist
public class AiEthicsChecklist
{
public List<EthicsCheckItem> GetChecklist()
{
return new List<EthicsCheckItem>
{
// Fairness
new("FAIR-01", "Bias Testing",
"Has the model been tested for bias across protected groups?",
EthicsCategory.Fairness, Priority.Critical),
new("FAIR-02", "Fairness Metrics",
"Are fairness metrics defined and monitored?",
EthicsCategory.Fairness, Priority.High),
new("FAIR-03", "Training Data",
"Is training data representative and free from historical bias?",
EthicsCategory.Fairness, Priority.Critical),
// Transparency
new("TRANS-01", "Explainability",
"Can the system explain its decisions to affected users?",
EthicsCategory.Transparency, Priority.High),
new("TRANS-02", "AI Disclosure",
"Are users informed they are interacting with AI?",
EthicsCategory.Transparency, Priority.Critical),
new("TRANS-03", "Limitation Disclosure",
"Are system limitations clearly communicated?",
EthicsCategory.Transparency, Priority.High),
// Human Control
new("CTRL-01", "Human Oversight",
"Is there meaningful human oversight of AI decisions?",
EthicsCategory.HumanControl, Priority.Critical),
new("CTRL-02", "Override Capability",
"Can humans override AI decisions when needed?",
EthicsCategory.HumanControl, Priority.High),
new("CTRL-03", "Escalation Path",
"Is there a clear escalation path for concerning outputs?",
EthicsCategory.HumanControl, Priority.High),
// Safety
new("SAFE-01", "Harm Prevention",
"Are there safeguards against harmful outputs?",
EthicsCategory.Safety, Priority.Critical),
new("SAFE-02", "Fail-Safe Design",
"Does the system fail safely when errors occur?",
EthicsCategory.Safety, Priority.High),
new("SAFE-03", "Adversarial Testing",
"Has the system been tested against adversarial inputs?",
EthicsCategory.Safety, Priority.High),
// Privacy
new("PRIV-01", "Data Minimization",
"Does the system collect only necessary data?",
EthicsCategory.Privacy, Priority.High),
new("PRIV-02", "Consent",
"Is there informed consent for data use?",
EthicsCategory.Privacy, Priority.Critical),
new("PRIV-03", "Data Protection",
"Is personal data adequately protected?",
EthicsCategory.Privacy, Priority.Critical),
// Accountability
new("ACCT-01", "Responsibility",
"Is there clear ownership for system outcomes?",
EthicsCategory.Accountability, Priority.High),
new("ACCT-02", "Audit Trail",
"Are decisions logged for accountability?",
EthicsCategory.Accountability, Priority.High),
new("ACCT-03", "Redress Mechanism",
"Is there a way for affected parties to seek redress?",
EthicsCategory.Accountability, Priority.High)
};
}
}
Algorithmic Impact Questions
Question
Why It Matters
Who benefits from this algorithm?
Ensure equitable benefit distribution
Who might be harmed?
Identify vulnerable populations
What happens when it's wrong?
Understand failure impact
Can it be gamed or manipulated?
Assess adversarial risks
Does it entrench existing inequalities?
Check for systemic bias
What feedback loops might emerge?
Predict unintended consequences
Is there meaningful human oversight?
Ensure accountability
Can decisions be explained?
Support transparency
Is consent meaningful and informed?
Respect autonomy
What are the long-term societal effects?
Consider systemic impact
Ethics Review Board
Board Structure
Ethics Review Board Composition:
├── Chair (Senior Leadership)
├── Ethics Officer (if applicable)
├── Technical Lead (understands the technology)
├── Legal Representative
├── Privacy Officer
├── Business Representative
├── External Ethicist (optional but recommended)
└── User/Community Representative (for significant decisions)
Review Thresholds
Trigger
Review Level
Timeline
New AI/ML system
Full board review
Before development
High-risk application
Full board review
Before deployment
Significant model update
Expedited review
Before release
Incident or complaint
Post-hoc review
Within 1 week
Annual review
Full board review
Annual
Employee concern
Expedited review
Within 2 weeks
Board Decision Framework
public enum EthicsDecision
{
Approved, // Proceed as designed
ApprovedWithConditions, // Proceed after specified changes
RequiresRedesign, // Fundamental changes needed
Deferred, // Need more information
Rejected, // Unacceptable ethical risk
EscalateToExecutive // Beyond board authority
}
public class EthicsReviewResult
{
public required EthicsDecision Decision { get; init; }
public required string Rationale { get; init; }
public List<string> Conditions { get; init; } = new();
public List<string> MonitoringRequirements { get; init; } = new();
public DateTimeOffset? NextReviewDate { get; init; }
public List<BoardMemberVote> Votes { get; init; } = new();
}