plan-gap-analysis

d-o-hub's avatarfrom d-o-hub

Analyze gaps between implementation plans and actual codebase implementation for the Rust self-learning memory project

⭐3stars🔀0forks📁View on GitHub🕐Updated Jan 3, 2026⬇️1downloads

When & Why to Use This Skill

This Claude skill provides a systematic gap analysis between documented implementation plans and the actual Rust codebase. It helps developers and project managers identify missing features, unimplemented security measures, and testing gaps, ensuring that the final product aligns perfectly with the architectural roadmap and functional requirements.

Use Cases

  • Project Progress Tracking: Automatically compare multi-phase roadmaps with current code to visualize development completion percentages and identify lagging components.
  • Quality Assurance Audit: Identify missing unit, integration, and performance tests that were specified in the planning phase but are currently absent from the codebase.
  • Security Compliance Check: Cross-reference security requirements and attack surface mitigations against the implementation to ensure all planned safety measures are active.
  • Technical Debt Identification: Detect unimplemented architectural decisions, missing data structures, or incomplete error handling that deviate from the original design specifications.
  • Automated TODO Generation: Create structured, prioritized task lists for development teams to bridge the gap between design documents and the live repository.
nameplan-gap-analysis
descriptionAnalyze gaps between implementation plans and actual codebase implementation for the Rust self-learning memory project

Plan Gap Analysis Skill

Systematically analyze the implementation status of the self-learning memory system by comparing the detailed plans in plans/ against the actual codebase implementation.

Purpose

This skill enables comprehensive gap analysis between:

  • Documented plans (Phase 1-6 in plans/ folder)
  • Actual implementation (Rust codebase)
  • Missing features, tests, and documentation
  • Unimplemented components from the roadmap

Workflow

Phase 1: Plan Inventory

  1. Read all plan files in plans/ directory:

    • 00-overview.md - Project summary and metrics
    • 01-understand.md - Requirements and components
    • 02-plan.md - Architecture decisions and roadmap
    • 03-execute.md - Implementation details
    • 04-review.md - Quality requirements
    • 05-secure.md - Security requirements
    • 06-feedback-loop.md - Refinements and improvements
  2. Extract requirements from each phase:

    • Functional requirements (FR1-FR7)
    • Non-functional requirements (NFR1-NFR6)
    • Data structures and types
    • Functions and APIs
    • Tests and benchmarks
    • Security measures

Phase 2: Codebase Inventory

  1. Scan Rust crates structure:

    # List all crates
    find . -name "Cargo.toml" -not -path "*/target/*"
    
    # List all Rust source files
    find . -name "*.rs" -not -path "*/target/*"
    
  2. Analyze each crate:

    • memory-core - Core data structures and memory orchestration
    • memory-storage-turso - Turso/libSQL storage backend
    • memory-storage-redb - redb cache layer
    • memory-mcp - MCP server and sandbox
    • test-utils - Test utilities
    • benches - Performance benchmarks
  3. Check implementation status:

    • Data structures (Episode, Pattern, Heuristic, etc.)
    • Core functions (start_episode, log_step, complete_episode, etc.)
    • Storage operations (CRUD, queries, sync)
    • Pattern extraction algorithms
    • MCP integration and sandboxing
    • Tests (unit, integration, benchmarks)

Phase 3: Gap Identification

For each phase, identify:

Phase 1 (UNDERSTAND) Gaps

  • Missing data structures from specification
  • Incomplete type definitions
  • Missing edge case handling

Phase 2 (PLAN) Gaps

  • Architectural decisions not implemented
  • Success metrics not tracked
  • Feature flags not implemented
  • Circuit breakers missing
  • Telemetry not fully implemented

Phase 3 (EXECUTE) Gaps

  • Storage agent deliverables incomplete
  • Learning agent features missing
  • MCP agent sandbox security incomplete
  • Sync mechanism not fully implemented

Phase 4 (REVIEW) Gaps

  • Compliance tests missing (FR1-FR7)
  • Performance tests incomplete (NFR1-NFR6)
  • Quality metrics not measured
  • Code coverage below 90%
  • Integration tests incomplete

Phase 5 (SECURE) Gaps

  • Security attack surface analysis missing
  • Sandbox escape prevention incomplete
  • SQL injection prevention validation missing
  • Resource limits not enforced
  • Network security not validated
  • Penetration tests not implemented

Phase 6 (FEEDBACK LOOP) Gaps

  • Edge case refinements not implemented
  • Performance optimizations pending
  • Two-phase commit not implemented
  • Pattern extraction queue missing
  • Schema migration not implemented

Phase 4: Prioritization

Categorize gaps by priority:

Critical (Blocks production):

  • Security vulnerabilities
  • Data corruption risks
  • Missing core functionality

High (Affects quality):

  • Performance targets not met
  • Test coverage below target
  • Missing error handling

Medium (Technical debt):

  • Code quality issues
  • Documentation gaps
  • Optimization opportunities

Low (Nice to have):

  • Future enhancements
  • Optional features
  • Cosmetic improvements

Phase 5: TODO Generation

Generate structured TODO list:

## Phase [N]: [PHASE_NAME]

### Critical Priority
- [ ] [Component] - [Missing item] (Week X deliverable)
  - **File**: path/to/file.rs
  - **Plan Reference**: plans/0X-phase.md:LineNumber
  - **Impact**: [Description of impact]
  - **Effort**: [Estimated effort]

### High Priority
- [ ] [Component] - [Missing item]
  ...

### Medium Priority
...

### Low Priority
...

Analysis Process

// Pseudo-code for analysis flow
async fn analyze_plan_gaps() -> GapAnalysisReport {
    let plans = read_all_plan_files().await;
    let codebase = scan_rust_codebase().await;

    let mut gaps = Vec::new();

    for phase in &plans {
        let requirements = extract_requirements(phase);
        let implementation = find_implementation(&codebase, &requirements);

        for req in requirements {
            if !implementation.contains(&req) {
                gaps.push(Gap {
                    phase: phase.number,
                    requirement: req,
                    priority: calculate_priority(&req),
                    file_location: find_best_location(&codebase, &req),
                    plan_reference: format_reference(phase, &req),
                });
            }
        }
    }

    GapAnalysisReport {
        total_requirements: count_all_requirements(&plans),
        implemented: codebase.count_implementations(),
        gaps: gaps.sorted_by_priority(),
        completion_percentage: calculate_completion(&gaps),
    }
}

Key Files to Analyze

Plans Directory

  • plans/00-overview.md - Success metrics and targets
  • plans/01-understand.md - All 47 core data structures
  • plans/02-plan.md - 12-week roadmap, success metrics
  • plans/03-execute.md - Week 1-2, 3-4, 5-6, 7-8 deliverables
  • plans/04-review.md - FR1-FR7, NFR1-NFR6 tests
  • plans/05-secure.md - Security attack surfaces and mitigations
  • plans/06-feedback-loop.md - Refinements and edge cases

Codebase to Check

Core Types (memory-core/src/):

  • types.rs - TaskContext, TaskType, ComplexityLevel, etc.
  • episode.rs - Episode, ExecutionStep, ExecutionResult
  • pattern.rs - Pattern enum variants, Heuristic
  • error.rs - Error types and Result
  • memory.rs - SelfLearningMemory main orchestrator
  • extraction.rs - PatternExtractor trait and implementations
  • reward.rs - RewardCalculator
  • reflection.rs - ReflectionGenerator
  • sync.rs - Storage synchronization

Storage (memory-storage-*/src/):

  • Turso: schema.rs, storage.rs (CRUD, queries)
  • redb: tables.rs, storage.rs (cache operations)

MCP (memory-mcp/src/):

  • server.rs - MCP server implementation
  • sandbox.rs - Code execution sandbox
  • types.rs - Tool definitions

Tests:

  • Unit tests in each module
  • Integration tests in tests/ directories
  • Benchmarks in benches/

Output Format

# Plan Gap Analysis Report
**Generated**: [Date]
**Project**: rust-self-learning-memory
**Total Requirements**: X
**Implemented**: Y (Z%)
**Gaps Identified**: N

## Executive Summary
- Phase 1: X/Y complete
- Phase 2: X/Y complete
- Phase 3: X/Y complete
- Phase 4: X/Y complete
- Phase 5: X/Y complete
- Phase 6: X/Y complete

## Detailed Gap Analysis

### Phase 1: UNDERSTAND
**Completion**: X%

#### Critical Gaps
1. [Gap description]
   - **Plan**: plans/01-understand.md:123
   - **Missing in**: memory-core/src/types.rs
   - **Priority**: Critical
   - **Effort**: [hours/days]

...

### Phase 2: PLAN
...

## Recommended Action Plan

### Week 1-2 Focus
- [ ] Critical gap 1
- [ ] Critical gap 2

### Week 3-4 Focus
...

## Metrics

| Metric | Target | Current | Status |
|--------|--------|---------|--------|
| Retrieval Latency (P95) | <100ms | TBD | 🔴 Not Tested |
| Pattern Accuracy | >70% | TBD | 🔴 Not Tested |
| Test Coverage | >90% | X% | 🟡 Below Target |
| Episode Capacity | 10,000+ | TBD | 🔴 Not Tested |
| Security Vulnerabilities | 0 critical | X | 🔴 Not Assessed |

Best Practices

  1. Be Systematic: Check every requirement in every plan
  2. Be Specific: Reference exact file locations and line numbers
  3. Be Accurate: Verify implementation, don't assume
  4. Be Prioritized: Critical > High > Medium > Low
  5. Be Actionable: Include file paths and effort estimates

Example Usage

When invoked, this skill will:

  1. Read all 8 plan markdown files
  2. Scan all Rust source files
  3. Cross-reference requirements vs implementation
  4. Generate prioritized TODO list by phase
  5. Output comprehensive gap analysis report