story-check
This skill provides the 12 critical story questions for screenplay evaluation.Covers concept, theme, audience reaction, beginning, ending, rising tensions,characters, protagonist, motivation, antagonist, and believability.Use when: evaluating a screenplay draft, identifying story weaknesses,preparing for rewrites, or validating fundamentals before submission.
When & Why to Use This Skill
The Story Check skill is a professional-grade screenplay evaluation framework designed to audit the structural integrity and emotional resonance of a script. By utilizing 12 critical narrative questions, it helps writers and editors analyze essential elements such as thematic depth, character motivation, rising tension, and narrative logic. This tool ensures that every aspect of a story—from the protagonist's 'point of no return' to the antagonist's credibility—is meticulously vetted for maximum audience impact and industry readiness.
Use Cases
- Pre-Submission Script Audit: Use the 12-question checklist to identify hidden story weaknesses and validate narrative fundamentals before submitting a screenplay to producers or competitions.
- Rewrite and Revision Planning: Analyze a rough draft to pinpoint specific areas requiring improvement, such as weak character stakes or lack of rising tension, to create a focused and effective rewrite strategy.
- Character Development Analysis: Evaluate the protagonist's empathy factor and the antagonist's motivations to ensure a compelling, high-stakes conflict that drives the story forward.
- Structural Logic Check: Assess the 'Beginning' and 'Ending' of a story to ensure the world-building is clear, the setup is not 'messy,' and the resolution fully satisfies the story's initial premise.
| name | story-check |
|---|---|
| wtfbId | wtfb:story-check |
| description | | |
| Use when | evaluating a screenplay draft, identifying story weaknesses, |
Story Check Skill
Invocation Triggers
Apply this skill when:
- Evaluating a screenplay draft
- Identifying story weaknesses
- Preparing for rewrites
- Validating story fundamentals before submission
The 12 Story Questions
Here are twelve great questions you should ask yourself about your script/story while you are developing it. You should actually chart it out.
Question 1: Story Elements
What are the elements of my story?
- What is my story's concept?
- What genre is my story?
CONCEPT: ___________________________________
GENRE: ___________________________________
Question 2: Message
What do I want to say with my script or story?
- The state of the world?
- Relationships?
- Governments?
- Religions?
- Life in general?
- People?
THEME/MESSAGE: ___________________________________
Question 3: Audience Reaction
How will audiences or readers react to my story?
- Interesting?
- Believable? Is it a true story?
- Credible?
- Compelling?
| Criterion | Rating (1-5) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Interesting | ||
| Believable | ||
| Credible | ||
| Compelling |
Question 4: Beginning
Where does my story begin?
- What is the setup?
- Is the protagonist in a crisis?
- Have you established your world? The rules?
- The restrictions?
SETUP: ___________________________________
WORLD RULES: ___________________________________
Question 5: Ending
Where does my story end?
- What is the outcome or resolution? And why?
- Do you answer any and all questions presented?
- Did you fulfill the premise of the story?
RESOLUTION: ___________________________________
QUESTIONS ANSWERED: [ ] Yes [ ] Partial [ ] No
PREMISE FULFILLED: [ ] Yes [ ] No
Question 6: Rising Tensions
Are there rising tensions?
- Are there surprises?
- How does the conflict escalate?
- Is there a climax?
SURPRISE COUNT: ___
ESCALATION PATTERN: ___________________________________
CLIMAX: ___________________________________
Question 7: Characters
Who are my characters?
- Are they likable?
- Interesting? Unique or different?
- Bigger than life?
- Will an audience care about them?
| Character | Likable | Interesting | Unique | Care Factor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Question 8: Protagonist
What or who is my protagonist like?
- Can audiences empathize with them?
- What do they want?
- What are their goals in life? Needs?
- What's at stake for them?
- Are they tied to the problem they face?
- Are they in a position of no turning back?
EMPATHY: [ ] Strong [ ] Moderate [ ] Weak
WANT: ___________________________________
NEED: ___________________________________
STAKES: ___________________________________
POINT OF NO RETURN: Page ___
Question 9: Motivation
What are my characters' motivations?
- Are these motivations shown?
- Justified or unjustified?
- Built into the story?
PROTAGONIST MOTIVATION: ___________________________________
SHOWN ON SCREEN: [ ] Yes [ ] No
JUSTIFIED: [ ] Yes [ ] No
BUILT INTO STORY: [ ] Yes [ ] No
Question 10: Antagonist
Who or what is the antagonist in my story?
- Why are they trying to stop your protagonist?
- Is the antagonist a worthy foe?
- What drives them?
- What do they want or need?
ANTAGONIST: ___________________________________
MOTIVATION: ___________________________________
WORTHY FOE: [ ] Yes [ ] No
WANT: ___________________________________
Question 11: Over-Explanation
Do I over-explain my story?
- Is everything spelled out too clearly?
- Is the setup "messy" and too busy?
- Do events get explained or unfold dramatically?
- Do too many key events take place off screen?
| Issue | Present? | Page(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Over-explanation | ||
| Messy setup | ||
| Told not shown | ||
| Key events off screen |
Question 12: Believability
If my story and characters are fictitious, can I now believe that they are real?
BELIEVABILITY SCORE: ___/10
AREAS TO IMPROVE: ___________________________________
Story Check Summary Template
## Story Check Summary: [TITLE]
### PASS/FAIL Assessment
| Question | Status | Notes |
|----------|--------|-------|
| 1. Elements | | |
| 2. Message | | |
| 3. Audience Reaction | | |
| 4. Beginning | | |
| 5. Ending | | |
| 6. Rising Tensions | | |
| 7. Characters | | |
| 8. Protagonist | | |
| 9. Motivation | | |
| 10. Antagonist | | |
| 11. Over-Explanation | | |
| 12. Believability | | |
### Critical Issues
1. ___________________________________
2. ___________________________________
3. ___________________________________
### Recommended Actions
1. ___________________________________
2. ___________________________________
3. ___________________________________
### Overall Assessment
[ ] Ready for submission
[ ] Needs minor revisions
[ ] Needs significant rewrite
[ ] Fundamental story issues
Validation Checklist
- All 12 questions answered honestly
- Issues documented with specific page references
- Action items prioritized
- Overall assessment reflects reality