formatting-audits
设计文档审查格式定义,包含100分评分系统。为SOW/Spec文档提供质量评估标准、评分项目和通过/失败逻辑。结合置信度标记(✓/→/?)以明确评估证据。在关键词上触发:"SOW review", "Spec review", "document review", "design review", "90 points", "scoring", "grading"
📖 中文导读:设计文档审查格式定义,包含100分评分系统。为SOW/Spec文档提供质量评估标准、评分项目和通过/失败逻辑。结合置信度标记(✓/→/?)以明确评估证据。在关键词上触发:"SOW review", "Spec review", "document review", "design review", "90 points", "scoring", "grading" 以下正文为该技能的原始 SKILL.md 内容(英文),上方安装命令可直接使用。
name: formatting-audits description: > Design document review format with 100-point scoring system for SOW/Spec. Use when reviewing SOW or Spec documents, scoring design quality, or when user mentions SOW review, Spec review, 設計書レビュー, 品質スコア, document scoring. allowed-tools: [Read, Grep, Glob] agent: sow-spec-reviewer context: fork user-invocable: false
SOW/Spec Scoring (100-point)
Scoring
| Category | Score | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy | 0-25 | ✓/→/? markers, evidence |
| Completeness | 0-25 | All sections, testable AC |
| Relevance | 0-25 | Goals ↔ solutions, no YAGNI |
| Actionability | 0-25 | Specific steps, feasibility |
Deductions
| Issue | Points |
|---|---|
| No confidence marker | -5 |
| Missing required section | -10 |
| AC without test scenario | -5 |
| Vague action item | -5 |
| YAGNI violation | -5 |
| Inconsistent AC-FR map | -10 |
Thresholds
| Score | Judgment | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 90-100 | PASS | Proceed to next phase |
| 70-89 | CONDITIONAL | Re-review after fixes |
| 0-69 | FAIL | Major revision needed |