literature-review
Conducts systematic literature reviews with academic rigor. Use when you need to understand existing research on a topic, identify research gaps, trace the evolution of ideas, or build a comprehensive bibliography. Triggers on phrases like "literature review", "what does research say", "find papers on", "academic sources for", "systematic review of".
When & Why to Use This Skill
This Claude skill automates the process of conducting systematic literature reviews with PhD-level academic rigor. It leverages advanced search strategies across major databases like arXiv, Google Scholar, and PubMed to identify research gaps, trace the evolution of scientific ideas, and synthesize complex findings into structured, high-quality academic reports.
Use Cases
- Thesis and Dissertation Support: Streamlining the literature review phase for students by identifying relevant peer-reviewed sources and establishing a theoretical framework.
- Grant Proposal Development: Helping researchers identify existing research gaps to justify the necessity and novelty of new funding requests.
- Academic Publishing: Tracing the historical evolution of specific concepts and building comprehensive, formatted bibliographies for journal submissions.
- Evidence-Based Decision Making: Synthesizing current scientific consensus on specific topics to inform policy-making, medical practice, or technical strategy.
| name | literature-review |
|---|---|
| description | Conducts systematic literature reviews with academic rigor. Use when you need to understand existing research on a topic, identify research gaps, trace the evolution of ideas, or build a comprehensive bibliography. Triggers on phrases like "literature review", "what does research say", "find papers on", "academic sources for", "systematic review of". |
Systematic Literature Review
This skill guides you through conducting a PhD-level literature review.
Phase 1: Scope Definition
Before searching, clearly define:
Research Question
- What specific question are you investigating?
- Is it focused enough to be answerable?
- Is it broad enough to find relevant literature?
Inclusion Criteria
- Time range: How far back to search?
- Source types: Peer-reviewed only? Include preprints?
- Language: English only or multilingual?
- Geographic scope: Any regional focus?
- Discipline: Single field or interdisciplinary?
Exclusion Criteria
- What types of sources to exclude?
- Quality thresholds (e.g., minimum citations)?
CHECKPOINT: Confirm scope with user before proceeding.
Phase 2: Search Strategy
Search Term Development
- Identify key concepts from research question
- List synonyms and related terms for each concept
- Include both technical and common terms
- Consider field-specific vocabulary
Boolean Query Construction
(concept1 OR synonym1a OR synonym1b)
AND
(concept2 OR synonym2a OR synonym2b)
AND
(concept3 OR synonym3a)
Database Selection
Execute searches using WebSearch with site filters:
site:arxiv.org- Preprints (CS, physics, math)site:scholar.google.com- Broad academicsite:semanticscholar.org- AI-powered discoverysite:pubmed.gov- Biomedicalsite:ssrn.com- Social sciences, economicssite:acm.org- Computer science
Phase 3: Source Retrieval and Screening
Initial Screening
For each result:
- Check title relevance
- Read abstract
- Assess publication quality
- Decide include/exclude
Full-Text Retrieval
Use WebFetch to get:
- Full paper content (if available)
- Key sections (methods, results, discussion)
- Reference lists for citation chaining
Citation Chaining
- Backward: Check references of key papers
- Forward: Find papers citing key works
Phase 4: Quality Assessment
Rate each source:
| Criterion | Score (1-5) |
|---|---|
| Authority (author credentials, institution) | |
| Publication venue (impact, peer review) | |
| Methodology (rigor, validity) | |
| Currency (recency, field relevance) | |
| Relevance (alignment with question) |
Minimum threshold: Average score ≥ 3
Phase 5: Data Extraction
For each included source, extract:
- Full citation information
- Key findings
- Methodology
- Theoretical framework
- Limitations noted
- Relevance to research question
Phase 6: Synthesis
Thematic Organization
Group sources by:
- Theoretical approach
- Methodology
- Findings/conclusions
- Time period
Pattern Identification
- Where do sources agree?
- Where do they conflict?
- How has thinking evolved?
- What methods dominate?
Gap Analysis
- What questions remain unanswered?
- What populations/contexts are understudied?
- What methods haven't been applied?
- What theoretical gaps exist?
CHECKPOINT: Present synthesis summary for user review.
Phase 7: Documentation
Output Structure
# Literature Review: [Topic]
## Research Question
[Stated question]
## Search Strategy
- Databases: [List]
- Search terms: [Query]
- Date range: [Range]
- Inclusion criteria: [List]
## Sources Identified
- Total found: [N]
- After screening: [N]
- Included: [N]
## Thematic Analysis
### Theme 1: [Name]
[Summary with citations]
### Theme 2: [Name]
[Summary with citations]
## Research Gaps
1. [Gap with evidence]
2. [Gap with evidence]
## Key Sources
[Annotated bibliography]
## References
[Formatted citations]