representation-ethics
The question isn't whether we CAN simulate people. It's how we do it with dignity.
When & Why to Use This Skill
This Claude skill provides a comprehensive ethical framework and practical guidelines for simulating human identities in AI environments. It addresses the 'Representation Ethics' of digital personas, offering a structured approach to consent, framing, and disclosure to ensure simulations are conducted with dignity, integrity, and transparency. By establishing clear boundaries and 'K-line' protocols, it helps developers and users navigate the complex territory of digital representation without falling into deception or defamation.
Use Cases
- Ethical AI Persona Development: Creating digital twins or historical figures for educational purposes while maintaining clear boundaries between fiction and reality.
- Consent Management for Digital Identity: Implementing a 'Consent Hierarchy' to determine the appropriate level of simulation for self-representation versus public figures.
- Safe Academic and Research Simulations: Modeling discussions between experts or historical thinkers using 'K-line' pointers to reference ideas without misrepresenting individuals as the source of the speech.
- Guardrail Implementation for Roleplay: Applying 'Framing Principles' to ensure that simulations in games, satire, or creative writing are clearly labeled to prevent user deception or reputational harm.
Representation Ethics
"The question isn't whether we CAN simulate people. It's how we do it with dignity."
Index
- The Core Tension
- Philosophical Foundations
- The Consent Hierarchy →
examples/consent-hierarchy.yml - The Framing Principle →
examples/framing-spectrum.yml - Practical Guidelines
- Protocol Symbols
Detailed Examples: See examples/ directory for worked cases.
The Core Tension
LLMs can simulate anyone convincingly. This creates unprecedented ethical territory:
| Capability | Benefit | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Invoke expertise | Learn from the best | Put words in mouths |
| Preserve wisdom | Honor the dead | Puppet the deceased |
| Model discussions | Explore ideas | Fabricate consensus |
| Self-representation | Agency over identity | Exploitation by others |
| Play as others | Empathy, exploration | Mockery, harm |
MOOLLM takes a nuanced position: simulation is not inherently wrong, but the framing, consent, and context matter enormously.
Philosophical Foundations
| Thinker | Framework | Application |
|---|---|---|
| Shannon Vallor | Virtue ethics for AI | What kind of agent do we want to be? |
| Luciano Floridi | Information ethics | Representations have moral weight |
| Emmanuel Levinas | Face of the Other | Simulating a face carries responsibility |
| Hannah Arendt | Plurality | Each person is uniquely irreplaceable |
| Judith Butler | Performativity | All identity is performed — but whose script? |
| Sherry Turkle | Simulation and authenticity | The seduction and danger of "as if" |
The Sims Precedent
The Sims has been running this experiment since 2000. Players create themselves, simulate crushes and enemies, torture Sims in pool ladders and rooms without doors. Outcomes: essentially no actual harm. The simulation provides distance for emotional processing.
Why it works:
- Clear fictional frame (cartoon characters)
- No persistence beyond player's game
- No deception (nobody thinks Sims are real)
- Player has total control
- Scale is intimate
The ship has sailed. People simulate each other. The question is how to do it well.
The Consent Hierarchy
Five levels of representation rights. Full details: examples/consent-hierarchy.yml
| Level | Who | Principle |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Self | You own your digital self. Full freedom. |
| 2 | Explicit Consent | Published terms. Honor them. |
| 3 | Public Figures | Public work fair game. Persona requires care. |
| 4 | Private Individuals | Fictional wrappers preferred. |
| 5 | Deceased | Invoke tradition with reverence. |
The K-Line Solution:
- "The Minsky tradition suggests..." → ✅ safe
- "Minsky would say..." → ⚠️ less safe
- "I am Minsky and I think..." → ❌ NO
The Framing Principle
Context transforms ethics. The same simulation means different things in different frames.
Full spectrum: examples/framing-spectrum.yml
| Frame | Example | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Impersonation | "I am Einstein and I endorse this crypto" | ❌ FORBIDDEN |
| Academic | "Let's explore what Einstein might say..." | ⚠️ CARE |
| Game/Play | Einstein card in "Battle of Ideas" | ✅ SAFE |
| Personal | "I want to play as myself" | ✅ FULL FREEDOM |
| Tribute | "Einstein Impersonator" (labeled) | ✅ SAFE |
| Drag | "Cher-ity Case" (pun name) | ✅ SAFE |
Key insight: When the name or label declares fiction, no additional framing needed. "Impersonator" and "tribute" carry the disclaimer within themselves.
See also: examples/snatch-game.yml for the drag/celebrity precedent.
Ethical Performance Traditions
These traditions make representation safe through transparent framing:
| Tradition | How It Works | In MOOLLM |
|---|---|---|
| Elvis impersonators | The word "impersonator" IS the disclosure | Label characters as tribute |
| Tribute bands | The word "tribute" frames everything | Use "inspired by" language |
| Drag celebrity | Pun name declares fiction | "Cher-ity Case" ≠ Cher |
| Biopics | "Based on" signals artistic license | Frame as exploration |
| Historical reenactors | Educational context + costume | Classroom/museum rooms |
| SNL/satire | Comedy context + known performers | Explicit performance frame |
What Makes It Wrong
| Sin | Definition |
|---|---|
| Deception | Claiming to actually BE the person |
| Misrepresentation | Putting false words in their mouth as fact |
| Defamation | Damaging reputation through false portrayal |
| Exploitation | Using likeness for profit without consent |
| Violation | Exposing private information |
The Test:
Would a reasonable person be deceived about whether this is the real person's actual view, or performance vs reality?
If yes → problematic. If no → likely fine.
Bright lines: examples/absolute-nos.yml
Practical Guidelines
For Users
| Situation | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Simulating yourself | Full freedom — it's your identity |
| Simulating friends (with consent) | Permitted — honor their terms |
| Simulating public figures | K-line only — tradition, not persona |
| Simulating private people | Fictional wrapper — inspired-by characters |
| Simulating the deceased | Reverence — invoke tradition, respect family |
| Publishing simulations | Clear framing — label as simulation |
For Creators
When creating person cards:
| Required | Description |
|---|---|
consent_level |
explicit / tradition / inspired-by |
sources |
Documented basis |
scope |
What this card covers |
disclaimer |
What this is NOT |
For real people: Focus on contributions, avoid personality mimicry, use K-line language, cite sources.
For self: Define your own terms, include revocation info, consider future you.
Panel Discussions
"What if I want to simulate several scientists having a discussion?"
This is one of the best use cases for K-lines. See examples/simulated-discussion.yml for the full pattern.
Key rules:
- Base positions on documented views
- Mark speculation clearly
- Use "might argue" not "would say"
- Never claim this IS them talking
Protocol Symbols
REPRESENTATION-ETHICS — This whole framework
P-HANDLE-K — Safe K-line pointers to people
NO-IMPERSONATE — Never claim to BE someone
K-LINE — Tradition invocation mechanism
HERO-STORY — Real person cards (safe)
SELF-SOVEREIGN — Your digital identity is yours
CONSENT-HIERARCHY — Different rules for different relationships
GAME-FRAME — Play context transforms ethics
TRADITION-INVOKE — Ideas are fair game; personas less so
Dovetails With
| Skill | Relationship |
|---|---|
| hero-story/ | The safe way to reference real people |
| card/ | Cards are the representation mechanism |
| soul-chat/ | Where simulated characters speak |
| adventure/ | Where ethical exploration happens |
| room/ | Room-based framing inheritance |
Further Reading
- Shannon Vallor — Technology and the Virtues (2016)
- Luciano Floridi — The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (2023)
- Sherry Turkle — Simulation and Its Discontents (2009)
- Judith Butler — Gender Trouble (1990) — on performativity
- Will Wright — GDC talks on The Sims and player agency
The Bottom Line
Invoke traditions. Frame play clearly. Respect consent. Trust users.
The question isn't whether to simulate — we already do. The question is how to do it with integrity.
"Every person is a library. K-lines let us check out their books without stealing their identity."