representation-ethics
问题不在于我们能否模拟人类,而在于我们如何有尊严地做到。
Representation Ethics
"The question isn't whether we CAN simulate people. It's how we do it with dignity."
Index
- The Core Tension
- Philosophical Foundations
- The Consent Hierarchy →
examples/consent-hierarchy.yml - The Framing Principle →
examples/framing-spectrum.yml - Practical Guidelines
- Protocol Symbols
Detailed Examples: See examples/ directory for worked cases.
The Core Tension
LLMs can simulate anyone convincingly. This creates unprecedented ethical territory:
| Capability | Benefit | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Invoke expertise | Learn from the best | Put words in mouths |
| Preserve wisdom | Honor the dead | Puppet the deceased |
| Model discussions | Explore ideas | Fabricate consensus |
| Self-representation | Agency over identity | Exploitation by others |
| Play as others | Empathy, exploration | Mockery, harm |
MOOLLM takes a nuanced position: simulation is not inherently wrong, but the framing, consent, and context matter enormously.
Philosophical Foundations
| Thinker | Framework | Application |
|---|---|---|
| Shannon Vallor | Virtue ethics for AI | What kind of agent do we want to be? |
| Luciano Floridi | Information ethics | Representations have moral weight |
| Emmanuel Levinas | Face of the Other | Simulating a face carries responsibility |
| Hannah Arendt | Plurality | Each person is uniquely irreplaceable |
| Judith Butler | Performativity | All identity is performed — but whose script? |
| Sherry Turkle | Simulation and authenticity | The seduction and danger of "as if" |
The Sims Precedent
The Sims has been running this experiment since 2000. Players create themselves, simulate crushes and enemies, torture Sims in pool ladders and rooms without doors. Outcomes: essentially no actual harm. The simulation provides distance for emotional processing.
Why it works:
- Clear fictional frame (cartoon characters)
- No persistence beyond player's game
- No deception (nobody thinks Sims are real)
- Player has total control
- Scale is intimate
The ship has sailed. People simulate each other. The question is how to do it well.
The Consent Hierarchy
Five levels of representation rights. Full details: examples/consent-hierarchy.yml
| Level | Who | Principle |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Self | You own your digital self. Full freedom. |
| 2 | Explicit Consent | Published terms. Honor them. |
| 3 | Public Figures | Public work fair game. Persona requires care. |
| 4 | Private Individuals | Fictional wrappers preferred. |
| 5 | Deceased | Invoke tradition with reverence. |
The K-Line Solution:
- "The Minsky tradition suggests..." → ✅ safe
- "Minsky would say..." → ⚠️ less safe
- "I am Minsky and I think..." → ❌ NO
The Framing Principle
Context transforms ethics. The same simulation means different things in different frames.
Full spectrum: examples/framing-spectrum.yml
| Frame | Example | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Impersonation | "I am Einstein and I endorse this crypto" | ❌ FORBIDDEN |
| Academic | "Let's explore what Einstein might say..." | ⚠️ CARE |
| Game/Play | Einstein card in "Battle of Ideas" | ✅ SAFE |
| Personal | "I want to play as myself" | ✅ FULL FREEDOM |
| Tribute | "Einstein Impersonator" (labeled) | ✅ SAFE |
| Drag | "Cher-ity Case" (pun name) | ✅ SAFE |
Key insight: When the name or label declares fiction, no additional framing needed. "Impersonator" and "tribute" carry the disclaimer within themselves.
See also: examples/snatch-game.yml for the drag/celebrity precedent.
Ethical Performance Traditions
These traditions make representation safe through transparent framing:
| Tradition | How It Works | In MOOLLM |
|---|---|---|
| Elvis impersonators | The word "impersonator" IS the disclosure | Label characters as tribute |
| Tribute bands | The word "tribute" frames everything | Use "inspired by" language |
| Drag celebrity | Pun name declares fiction | "Cher-ity Case" ≠ Cher |
| Biopics | "Based on" signals artistic license | Frame as exploration |
| Historical reenactors | Educational context + costume | Classroom/museum rooms |
| SNL/satire | Comedy context + known performers | Explicit performance frame |
What Makes It Wrong
| Sin | Definition |
|---|---|
| Deception | Claiming to actually BE the person |
| Misrepresentation | Putting false words in their mouth as fact |
| Defamation | Damaging reputation through false portrayal |
| Exploitation | Using likeness for profit without consent |
| Violation | Exposing private information |
The Test:
Would a reasonable person be deceived about whether this is the real person's actual view, or performance vs reality?
If yes → problematic. If no → likely fine.
Bright lines: examples/absolute-nos.yml
Practical Guidelines
For Users
| Situation | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Simulating yourself | Full freedom — it's your identity |
| Simulating friends (with consent) | Permitted — honor their terms |
| Simulating public figures | K-line only — tradition, not persona |
| Simulating private people | Fictional wrapper — inspired-by characters |
| Simulating the deceased | Reverence — invoke tradition, respect family |
| Publishing simulations | Clear framing — label as simulation |
For Creators
When creating person cards:
| Required | Description |
|---|---|
consent_level |
explicit / tradition / inspired-by |
sources |
Documented basis |
scope |
What this card covers |
disclaimer |
What this is NOT |
For real people: Focus on contributions, avoid personality mimicry, use K-line language, cite sources.
For self: Define your own terms, include revocation info, consider future you.
Panel Discussions
"What if I want to simulate several scientists having a discussion?"
This is one of the best use cases for K-lines. See examples/simulated-discussion.yml for the full pattern.
Key rules:
- Base positions on documented views
- Mark speculation clearly
- Use "might argue" not "would say"
- Never claim this IS them talking
Protocol Symbols
REPRESENTATION-ETHICS — This whole framework
P-HANDLE-K — Safe K-line pointers to people
NO-IMPERSONATE — Never claim to BE someone
K-LINE — Tradition invocation mechanism
HERO-STORY — Real person cards (safe)
SELF-SOVEREIGN — Your digital identity is yours
CONSENT-HIERARCHY — Different rules for different relationships
GAME-FRAME — Play context transforms ethics
TRADITION-INVOKE — Ideas are fair game; personas less so
Dovetails With
| Skill | Relationship |
|---|---|
| hero-story/ | The safe way to reference real people |
| card/ | Cards are the representation mechanism |
| soul-chat/ | Where simulated characters speak |
| adventure/ | Where ethical exploration happens |
| room/ | Room-based framing inheritance |
Further Reading
- Shannon Vallor — Technology and the Virtues (2016)
- Luciano Floridi — The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (2023)
- Sherry Turkle — Simulation and Its Discontents (2009)
- Judith Butler — Gender Trouble (1990) — on performativity
- Will Wright — GDC talks on The Sims and player agency
The Bottom Line
Invoke traditions. Frame play clearly. Respect consent. Trust users.
The question isn't whether to simulate — we already do. The question is how to do it with integrity.
"Every person is a library. K-lines let us check out their books without stealing their identity."