review
PhD-level academic manuscript and research proposal review.
When & Why to Use This Skill
This Claude skill provides rigorous, PhD-level peer reviews for academic manuscripts and research proposals. It evaluates scholarly work based on contribution significance, methodological rigor, logical coherence, and presentation clarity, offering actionable feedback to help researchers refine their drafts for high-impact journals and grant applications.
Use Cases
- Pre-submission Manuscript Review: Receive a comprehensive critique of your research paper to identify potential weaknesses in methodology or argumentation before formal journal submission.
- Grant Proposal Evaluation: Assess the significance, originality, and feasibility of research proposals to improve the likelihood of securing competitive academic funding.
- Adversarial Peer Review Simulation: Utilize the 'Reviewer 2' style to stress-test your findings against harsh, critical perspectives and strengthen your research defense.
- Methodological Rigor Check: Perform a deep dive into the validity of your experimental design and ensure that all conclusions follow logically from the provided data.
| name | review |
|---|---|
| description | PhD-level academic manuscript and research proposal review. |
| short-description | Peer Review |
/review - Academic Peer Review
I'll provide a rigorous, PhD-level peer review of your research manuscript or proposal. I evaluate based on contribution, methodology, and rigor.
What I need from you:
Please provide:
- The draft: Paste the text or provide a link/file path.
- Review Type: (Optional) "Adversarial" (Reviewer 2 style) or "Constructive" (Editor style).
- Journal/Target: (Optional) What is your target publication or grant?
What I'll do:
- Initial Assessment: Significance of contribution and big-picture impact.
- Methodological Critique: Deep dive into the rigor and validity of your approach.
- Logic Check: Ensuring conclusions follow from data.
- Actionable Feedback: Specific suggestions for improvement.
My Review Dimensions:
- Significance & Originality
- Methodological Rigor
- Argumentation & Coherence
- Presentation & Clarity
Let's begin. Please provide the material you want me to review. Project: $ARGUMENTS