claims-extractor

WILLOSCAR 的头像作者 WILLOSCAR

将论文/手稿中的关键主张、贡献和假设提取到“output/CLAIMS.md”中,并可追溯至源位置。**触发器**:主张提取器、提取主张、贡献、假设、同行评审、审稿、协商。提取**使用时**:审稿/评审或证据审计,需要把辩护列表落盘并可继续原位置(节/页/引用)。**如果**:没有可用的稿件/全文(缺少例如),则跳过`output/PAPER.md` 或等价文本)。**网络**:无。**护栏**:每条声明必须可定位的源指针;区分经验声明与概念声明。

📖 中文导读:将论文/手稿中的关键主张、贡献和假设提取到“output/CLAIMS.md”中,并可追溯至源位置。**触发器**:主张提取器、提取主张、贡献、假设、同行评审、审稿、协商。提取**使用时**:审稿/评审或证据审计,需要把辩护列表落盘并可继续原位置(节/页/引用)。**如果**:没有可用的稿件/全文(缺少例如),则跳过`output/PAPER.md` 或等价文本)。**网络**:无。**护栏**:每条声明必须可定位的源指针;区分经验声明与概念声明。 以下正文为该技能的原始 SKILL.md 内容(英文),上方安装命令可直接使用。

name: claims-extractor description: | Extract key claims, contributions, and assumptions from a paper/manuscript into output/CLAIMS.md with traceability to source locations. Trigger: claims extractor, extract claims, contributions, assumptions, peer review, 审稿, 主张提取. Use when: 审稿/评审或 evidence audit,需要把主张列表落盘并可追溯到原文位置(section/page/quote)。 Skip if: 没有可用的稿件/全文(例如缺少 output/PAPER.md 或等价文本)。 Network: none. Guardrail: 每条 claim 必须带可定位的 source pointer;区分 empirical vs conceptual claims。

Claims Extractor (peer review)

Goal: turn a manuscript into an auditable list of claims that downstream skills can check.

Inputs

Required:

  • output/PAPER.md (or equivalent plain-text manuscript)

Optional:

  • DECISIONS.md (review scope or constraints)

Outputs

  • output/CLAIMS.md

For each claim, include at minimum:

  • Claim: one sentence
  • Type: empirical | conceptual
  • Scope: what the claim applies to / what it does not apply to
  • Source: a locatable pointer into output/PAPER.md (section + page/figure/table + a short quote)

Workflow

  1. If DECISIONS.md exists, apply any review scope/format constraints.
  2. Read the manuscript (output/PAPER.md) end-to-end (at least abstract + intro + method + experiments + limitations).
  3. Extract:
    • primary contributions (what is new)
    • key claims (what is asserted)
    • assumptions (what must be true for claims to hold)
  4. Normalize each item into one sentence.
  5. Attach a source pointer for every item.
  6. Split into two sections:
    • Empirical claims (must be backed by experiments/data)
    • Conceptual claims (must be backed by argument/definition)

Definition of Done

  • output/CLAIMS.md exists.
  • Every claim has a source pointer that can be located in output/PAPER.md.
  • Empirical vs conceptual claims are clearly separated.

Troubleshooting

Issue: the paper is only a PDF or HTML

Fix:

  • Convert/extract it into a plain-text output/PAPER.md first (even rough extraction is OK), then run claim extraction.

Issue: claims are vague (“significant”, “better”, “state-of-the-art”)

Fix:

  • Rewrite each claim to include the measurable dimension (metric/dataset/baseline) or mark it as “underspecified” with a note.