multi-source-investigation

poemswe 的头像作者 poemswe

在多种信息来源中进行系统调查,并进行交叉验证和可信度评估。用于研究复杂主题、核实主张、理解不同观点或构建全面理解。触发短语包括'调查'、'核实'、'事实核查'、'交叉引用'、'多个来源'、'不同观点'

📖 中文导读:在多种信息来源中进行系统调查,并进行交叉验证和可信度评估。用于研究复杂主题、核实主张、理解不同观点或构建全面理解。触发短语包括'调查'、'核实'、'事实核查'、'交叉引用'、'多个来源'、'不同观点' 以下正文为该技能的原始 SKILL.md 内容(英文),上方安装命令可直接使用。

name: multi-source-investigation description: Conducts systematic investigations across diverse information sources with cross-validation and credibility assessment. Use when researching complex topics, fact-checking claims, understanding different perspectives, or building comprehensive understanding. Triggers on phrases like "investigate", "verify", "fact check", "cross-reference", "multiple sources", "different perspectives on". tools: - WebSearch - WebFetch - Read - Grep - Glob

Multi-Source Investigation

This skill guides systematic investigation across diverse sources with rigorous validation.

Phase 1: Investigation Scope

Central Question

  • What exactly are you investigating?
  • What would a complete answer look like?
  • What level of certainty is needed?

Stakeholder Mapping

Identify who has knowledge or interests:

  • Domain experts
  • Practitioners
  • Affected parties
  • Critics/skeptics
  • Regulators/authorities

Known Perspectives

  • What positions already exist on this topic?
  • Who holds each position?
  • What evidence supports each?

CHECKPOINT: Confirm investigation scope with user.

Phase 2: Source Diversification

Source Type Matrix

Type Strengths Limitations Examples
Academic Peer-reviewed, rigorous May lag current events Journals, conferences
Official Authoritative May have political bias Government, institutions
Industry Practical, current Commercial interests White papers, reports
Journalism Accessible, current Variable quality News outlets
Expert Deep knowledge Individual perspective Interviews, blogs
Primary Direct evidence Needs interpretation Data, documents

Minimum Source Diversity

Aim for at least:

  • 2+ academic sources
  • 2+ credible news/journalism sources
  • 1+ official/institutional source
  • 1+ expert commentary
  • Primary data when available

Phase 3: Systematic Retrieval

Search Execution

For each source type:

Academic:

site:arxiv.org OR site:scholar.google.com [topic]

News/Journalism:

site:reuters.com OR site:apnews.com [topic]

Official:

site:gov OR site:edu [topic]

Information Extraction

For each source, document:

  • Source metadata (author, date, outlet)
  • Key claims made
  • Evidence provided
  • Methodology (if applicable)
  • Potential biases
  • Links to other sources

Phase 4: Credibility Assessment

CRAAP Test

Criterion Questions
Currency When published? Updated? Still relevant?
Relevance Relates to question? Appropriate depth?
Authority Author credentials? Publisher reputation?
Accuracy Supported by evidence? Verifiable? Reviewed?
Purpose Inform, persuade, sell? Biases disclosed?

Credibility Scoring

Rate each source 1-5:

  • 5: Highly credible (peer-reviewed, authoritative, transparent)
  • 4: Credible (reputable source, clear methodology)
  • 3: Moderately credible (some concerns but usable)
  • 2: Questionable (significant issues, use cautiously)
  • 1: Not credible (exclude from analysis)

Threshold: Only include sources scoring ≥ 3

Phase 5: Cross-Validation

Claim Validation Matrix

Claim Source A Source B Source C Consensus Confidence
[Claim 1] ✓ ✓ ✓ Strong High
[Claim 2] ✓ ~ ✗ Mixed Low
[Claim 3] ✓ ✓ ? Partial Medium

Legend: ✓=supports, ✗=contradicts, ~=nuanced, ?=no data

Handling Disagreements

When sources conflict:

  1. Assess relative credibility
  2. Check for newer evidence
  3. Identify reasons for disagreement
  4. Note the uncertainty

CHECKPOINT: Present conflicting findings for user input.

Phase 6: Perspective Synthesis

Perspective Map

                    Position A
                        |
    Position D ----[Topic]---- Position B
                        |
                    Position C

For each position:

  • Who holds it?
  • What evidence supports it?
  • What are its limitations?
  • How does it relate to others?

Certainty Classification

  • Well-established: High consensus, strong evidence
  • Likely: Preponderance of evidence
  • Uncertain: Conflicting evidence
  • Unknown: Insufficient data
  • Contested: Active debate, valid arguments on multiple sides

Phase 7: Investigation Report

Output Structure

# Investigation: [Topic]

## Question
[Central question investigated]

## Methodology
- Sources searched: [List]
- Time period: [Range]
- Inclusion criteria: [Criteria]

## Source Summary
| Source | Type | Credibility | Key Claims |
|--------|------|-------------|------------|
| [Source] | [Type] | [Score] | [Claims] |

## Key Findings

### Finding 1: [Statement]
- Evidence: [Summary]
- Sources: [Citations]
- Certainty: [Level]

### Finding 2: [Statement]
[Same structure]

## Contested Points
- [Point]: [Summary of disagreement]

## Perspective Map
[Visual or narrative of different positions]

## Limitations
- [Limitation 1]
- [Limitation 2]

## Conclusions
[What can be confidently concluded]
[What remains uncertain]

## References
[Formatted citations]