novelty-matrix

WILLOSCAR 的头像作者 WILLOSCAR

创建一个新颖性/先前工作矩阵,将提交的贡献与相关工作进行比较(重叠与增量)。**触发器**:新颖性矩阵,先前工作矩阵,重叠/增量,相关对比,新颖性矩阵。**使用时**:同行评审中评估新颖性/定位,需要把贡献与相关工作逐项对齐并写出差异点。**如果**:证明工作新颖性声明(先跑)则跳过`claims-extractor`)或你不打算做新颖性定位分析。**网络**:无(除非提供,否则检索额外的相关工作超出范围)。**护栏**:与增量明显重叠;尽量给出可回溯证据来源(来自稿件/引用/作者陈述)。

📖 中文导读:创建一个新颖性/先前工作矩阵,将提交的贡献与相关工作进行比较(重叠与增量)。**触发器**:新颖性矩阵,先前工作矩阵,重叠/增量,相关对比,新颖性矩阵。**使用时**:同行评审中评估新颖性/定位,需要把贡献与相关工作逐项对齐并写出差异点。**如果**:证明工作新颖性声明(先跑)则跳过`claims-extractor`)或你不打算做新颖性定位分析。**网络**:无(除非提供,否则检索额外的相关工作超出范围)。**护栏**:与增量明显重叠;尽量给出可回溯证据来源(来自稿件/引用/作者陈述)。 以下正文为该技能的原始 SKILL.md 内容(英文),上方安装命令可直接使用。

name: novelty-matrix description: | Create a novelty/prior-work matrix comparing the submission’s contributions against related work (overlaps vs deltas). Trigger: novelty matrix, prior-work matrix, overlap/delta, 相关工作对比, 新颖性矩阵. Use when: peer review 中评估 novelty/positioning,需要把贡献与相关工作逐项对齐并写出差异点证据。 Skip if: 缺少 claims(先跑 claims-extractor)或你不打算做新颖性定位分析。 Network: none (retrieval of additional related work is out-of-scope unless provided). Guardrail: 明确 overlap 与 delta;尽量给出可追溯证据来源(来自稿件/引用/作者陈述)。

Novelty Matrix (overlap vs delta)

Goal: make novelty/positioning concrete by aligning each contribution against the closest prior work.

Inputs

Required:

  • output/CLAIMS.md

Optional:

  • A provided list of related work (titles/URLs/DOIs) or the submission’s reference list

Outputs

  • output/NOVELTY_MATRIX.md
  • Rows: contributions/claims (from output/CLAIMS.md)
  • Columns: closest related works (provided or cited by the paper)
  • For each row/column, record:
    • overlap: what is the same
    • delta: what is different/new
    • evidence: where this is supported (paper statement / citation / method difference)

Workflow

  1. Extract the contribution list from output/CLAIMS.md.
  2. Pick ≥5 closest related works (or state explicitly why you cannot).
  3. For each contribution, compare to each related work:
    • identify overlap
    • identify delta
    • attach evidence (quote/section/citation pointer)
  4. Summarize:
    • which contributions look clearly novel
    • which ones look like incremental variants

Definition of Done

  • Matrix includes ≥5 related works or explains why unavailable.
  • Every “delta” entry has a short evidence pointer (not just opinion).

Troubleshooting

Fix:

  • Use the paper’s own citations as the initial related set; if even that is missing, mark needs_related_work_list and stop.

Issue: overlap/delta becomes vague

Fix:

  • Force each cell to reference a concrete axis (problem setting, method component, training data, evaluation protocol, result).