name: peer-review
description: Systematic peer review and self-evaluation toolkit. Evaluate methodology, statistics, experimental design, reproducibility, ethics, and reporting standards. Use during the REVIEW phase to assess manuscript quality before submission, or when reviewing others' work.
Scientific Peer Review
Rigorously evaluate scientific work for quality, validity, and reproducibility.
When to Use
Self-reviewing manuscript before submission (REVIEW phase)
Evaluating methodology and experimental design
Checking statistical analyses and reporting
Assessing reproducibility and data availability
Reviewing others' manuscripts for journals
Evaluating grant proposals
Quality checking your own work during ANALYSIS phase
Check adherence to discipline-specific guidelines:
Study Type
Guideline
Status
Randomized trial
CONSORT
☐
Observational
STROBE
☐
Systematic review
PRISMA
☐
Diagnostic study
STARD
☐
Animal research
ARRIVE
☐
Case report
CARE
☐
Stage 5: Figure and Table Review
Quality Checks
Check
Question
Status
Resolution
High quality?
☐
Labels
All axes/columns labeled with units?
☐
Error bars
Defined (SD, SEM, CI)?
☐
Statistics
Significance markers explained?
☐
Color
Colorblind-friendly?
☐
Scale bars
Included for images?
☐
Integrity Checks
Check
Question
Status
Manipulation
Any signs of image manipulation?
☐
Splicing
Gels/blots appropriately presented?
☐
Representative
Images truly representative?
☐
Complete
All conditions shown?
☐
Stage 6: Writing Quality
Structure and Organization
Check
Question
Status
Logic
Manuscript logically organized?
☐
Flow
Sections flow coherently?
☐
Transitions
Clear between ideas?
☐
Narrative
Compelling and clear?
☐
Writing Quality
Check
Question
Status
Clarity
Language clear and precise?
☐
Jargon
Minimized and defined?
☐
Grammar
Correct throughout?
☐
Concise
No unnecessary complexity?
☐
Structuring the Review Report
Summary Statement (1-2 paragraphs)
## Summary
[Brief synopsis of the research]
**Recommendation**: [Accept / Minor revisions / Major revisions / Reject]
**Key Strengths**:
1. [Strength 1]
2. [Strength 2]
3. [Strength 3]
**Key Weaknesses**:
1. [Weakness 1]
2. [Weakness 2]
**Bottom Line**: [Overall assessment of significance and soundness]
Major Comments
Issues that significantly impact validity or interpretability:
## Major Comments
1. **[Issue Title]**
- *Problem*: [Clear statement of the issue]
- *Why it matters*: [Impact on conclusions]
- *Suggestion*: [How to address it]
2. **[Issue Title]**
...
Major issues typically include:
Fundamental methodological flaws
Inappropriate statistical analyses
Unsupported conclusions
Missing critical controls
Reproducibility concerns
Minor Comments
Less critical issues that would improve the manuscript:
## Minor Comments
1. [Page/Figure X]: [Issue and suggestion]
2. [Methods section]: [Missing detail]
3. [Figure 2]: [Clarity improvement]